Here’s why Pink Floyd stalwarts Roger Waters and David Gilmore despise one another after working together to create magic throughout their respective eras. Pink Floyd, a musical legend, became one of the most adored and financially successful bands of the 1970s thanks in part to Roger Waters and David Gilmore. Waters and Gilmore, both outstanding artists, helped to create Pink Floyd’s distinctive and progressive sound. They managed the creation of classic albums like “The Wall” and “The Dark Side of the Moon.” The band produced raw art because a lot of their work was emotional and depressing in nature. Although Waters and Gilmore succeeded in making Pink Floyd a well-known band around the world, they had trouble working together and maintaining a healthy personal connection.
Why Do Roger Waters And David Gilmore Hate Each Other?
Far Out claims that Roger Waters and David Gilmore have had a tumultuous relationship for a very long time. When Gilmore originally joined Pink Floyd in 1968, Waters and the other band members welcomed him. Gilmore was a gifted guitarist and singer who brought a great deal of value to the group, particularly following the loss of fellow founding member Syd Barrett. As an initial member of the band, Waters was a complex artist who was a stickler for detail. In addition, he was domineering and desired to guide Pink Floyd’s artistic course.
This isn’t always a terrible thing, either, because Waters was the mastermind behind the 1979 critically and commercially successful concept album “The Wall.” But Waters’s juvenile “my way or the highway” mentality made him difficult to work with. As Pink Floyd’s popularity grew, a dispute arose between Waters and Gilmore regarding creative authority. Every one of them had a different idea about how the band would sound and develop musically. The obstinate and brash Waters did not want Gilmore to be Pink Floyd’s leader. Gilmore and Waters’s conflict resulted from this mutual struggle.
In the end, Waters concluded that it was time to depart from Pink Floyd in 1985. In April 1984, he released his debut solo album, “The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking,” marking the beginning of his solo music career. Since he considered himself to be the group’s de facto creative leader, Waters thought that his departure from Pink Floyd would spell the end of the group. Waters’s conceited behavior made his conflict with Gilmore even more intense. Despite the animosity between Waters and Gilmore, Gilmore thought Pink Floyd was still creatively important and could have a future beyond Waters, according to Far Out.
According to Grunge, Waters later sued Gilmore and the other members of Pink Floyd in 1986 over the rights to the moniker “Pink Floyd.” Gilmore and Waters eventually came to an agreement on the litigation. The legal dispute between Waters and Gilmore in 1986 was by no means their final one. Over the years, they have engaged in constant conflict over things pertaining to Pink Floyd or personal affairs. In particular, Waters and Gilmore have engaged in heated arguments with one another via websites, interviews, and social media platforms. In May 2020, Waters criticized Gilmore in a video message he released on his X (formerly Twitter) account, saying:
“David thinks he owns it. I think he thinks that because I left the band in 1985, that he owns Pink Floyd, that he is Pink Floyd and I’m irrelevant and I should just keep my mouth shut.” Gilmore denounced Waters in 2021 over a problem involving a scheduled “Animals” re-release. The difficulty was candidly mentioned by Gilmore in an interview, saying, “A very lovely Animals remix has been done, but someone has tried to force some liner notes on it that I haven’t approved.” In response, Waters issued an official statement denying Gilmore’s assertion that he was merely trying to update liner notes in order to get more credit. In February 2023, Waters and Gilmore engaged in another online dispute. Polly Samson, Gilmore’s wife, posted a direct criticism of Waters on X:
“Sadly @rogerwaters you are antisemitic to your rotten core. Also a Putin apologist and a lying, thieving, hypocritical, tax-avoiding, lip-synching, misogynistic, sick-with-envy, megalomaniac. Enough of your nonsense.” Retweeting his wife’s remarks, Gilmore supported her assertions. Gilmore retweeted the message, saying, “Every word demonstrably true.” In a response, Waters’s X account said that she is aware of Samson’s charges, completely refutes them, and is consulting with counsel regarding how to proceed. Although it is impossible to verify or refute Samson’s claim, Waters does not have an impeccable reputation. It is said that he has declined to sign autographs for certain fans. He has also a history of making controversial, strongly worded political remarks. ABC News reports that Waters gave a concert in Germany in 2023 and that there may have been hints of antisemitic sentiment in his performance.
Did Roger Waters And David Gilmore Ever Have Peace After Pink Floyd?
Roger Waters and David Gilmore performed at a Pink Floyd reunion in 2005 as part of the Live 8 charity event in London. Legends including Paul McCartney, U2, Mariah Carey, The Who, and Coldplay were also on the bill. For the first time in almost 20 years, Waters, Gilmore, and the other members of Pink Floyd got together to give their fans a once-in-a-lifetime concert.
Even though Gilmore and Waters were undoubtedly not the greatest of friends, they managed to set aside their differences to honor Pink Floyd’s lasting legacy and share in its celebration. Among the songs they played at the concert were classics: When the show was over and Gilmore headed backstage, Waters angrily yelled for him to come back on stage, and the entire band gave each other hugs. Gilmore and Waters enjoyed the rewards of their effort together and were at peace for a little period of time. Waters finally admitted, according to the BBC, that “I was wrong to sue Pink Floyd” in 2013. As seen by their disagreements in 2020, 2021, and 2023, Waters and Gilmore are still at odds even though he has expressed sorrow for some of his actions.